Dog Health Questions: My dog has a severe growling problem?

She is a pomeranian about 5 almost 6 pounds and now its to the point to where when i say "STOP" she doesn't stop anymore its not barking at all just growling and it is getting worse and worse so i want to buy a shock collar but im afraid that it wont work even if i do get the shock collar because they are more for barking dogs. she no longer growls at something specific she just growls at birds , people walking next door (we live in a duplex) she growls at the wind , rain etc My question is WILL a shock collar stop her growling?
a simple yes or no will work.

This is the shock collar i want.

http://cgi.ebay.com/Bark-Dog-Training-Shock-Control-No-Barking-Collar-/360348171872?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item53e66cbe60

Dog Training Tips - Negative Reinforcement Vs. Positive Reinforcement - Which Is More Effective?

Recommended Answer:
She sounds like a very worried, understimulated dog.

Growling isn't a bad thing. It's done in play, and is also the most recognized sign preceding a bite. Take away the dogs growl and you may find yourself with a dog who "bites out of nowhere".

What would you rather have. A dog who is uncomfortable with something and let's you know with a growl? Which at that time you can work on the issue to make the dog more comfortable with it. Or one who says "Screw "telling" you I'm uncomfortable, I'm just going to put a few holes in your arm instead"

Skip the collar and hire a trainer to help you.

Learn the Significance of Dog Training Courses

• Yes! My dog had the same problem, and I got a shock collar. She doesn't growl hardly at all anymore! It's truly a great device. Go for it!


• shock her and see if it works!!!Lol


• You have to be very careful using a shock collar on small dogs as it can actually stop their heart if you don't use one that is specifically made for small dogs. Do a lot of research and talk to a knowledgeable veterinarian before trying this. If it were my dog, I would try someother methods first, as these "shock" methods can sometimes frighten small dogs and make them worse. Research books and web sites on dog training. Maybe even enroll in an obedience course where the instructor can evaluate your dog and her specific concerns. I would not advocate using a shock collar in most cases.