but to my question: after my dilemma with the dog collar, i realized that my dog seems to be unhappy sleeping outside. my neighbor, who has given me most of my dog training advice, told me that humans belong inside, and dogs belong outside. this seems cruel to me, but he insists that animals should not be spoiled. like i said before, you chicagoans know how cold it was this last week. i feel i should bring my dog in, you know, just for the winter. would this be spoiling the dog? (the dog does have a doghouse outside) it just seems so cold out there and i think i should make an exception and bring the dog in.
Dog Training School
Recommended Answer:
Bring your dog inside
Nothing is wrong with bringing a dog inside
and a dog can die outside if it too cold.
i leave in Louisiana so i dont know how cold it is over there
but i have one dog inside and hes a mini rat terrier.
Its ok to have a dog inside. Some vets recommend doing that to small dogs,old dogs,and weather condition.
Most certainly bring him inside
Using Dog Training Collars to Train Your Dog
- bring the dog in, I live in CA and it's cold her, but I know Chicago is much colder. My dog comes in but is still disciplined whether in or out. Tell your neighbor to buzz off, it's your house and your dog. Bring it in!!!
- umm...why would you even listen to someone that dumb?
yes you can bring your dog inside and NO it is not spoiling it!
i keep my dog inside all the time unless she WANTS to go outside...
wow thats cruel to keep your dog outside in such conditions. - Ok, your neighbor cannot dictate the way you treat your dog. That is like telling someone else how to raise their children. Both of my dogs are indoor dogs. If the weather is decent, I will leave them out all day. At night, they come in and sleep inside. They are not allowed on the furniture and they do not sleep with me. they have their own areas with blankets where they nap. If it's below freezing and your dog is not a husky, it is cruel to leave them outside. Just because dogs have fur, does not mean they cannot get cold. A spoiled dog is a dog who does whatever it pleases, does not listen, eats whatever it wishes and expects to get what it wants; just like a child. Being indoors is not going to spoil your dog. My dogs are indoor dogs but are quieter, more polite and better behaved than most of the outdoor dogs in me neighborhood. So, for pete's sake, ignore the neighbor and let him in. If you need more dog help, I've got 2 ( a dane and a husky mix) and would love to help you out, since it seems your neighbor is a bit harsh on her views of dog treatment.
- I have a shepard/ husky. Rather heavy coated. She has an insulated dog house with new straw. I live North of you in MI. I still let her inside when the windchill gets so bad out it takes your breath away. If Im not home? She will be in the garage. Dogs can get frost bitten also.
- Your neighbor is wrong. Dogs belong with their people.
Dogs are social animals. It really has nothing to do with the temperature or any thing like that. A dog that is with their owners, at least at night or when you are home is a better behaved and happier dog. Big dogs like to be outside for a while when the weather is nice but not 24/7. - Yes. There is absolutely no question here. It is FAR too cold outside to leave him out there. Dogs are pack animals, allowing them to be with their pack is not spoiling them, its enocuraging them to see you as their pack leader. How can he feel like a member of your pack if he is locked outside, bring him in and let him know that he is a member of the family but not the head of it.
Depending on what kind of dog he is leaving him outside in weather like this could be lethal and depending on where in Chicago you live it is more then likely illegal because it is so cruel and so dangerous.
Please stop listening to your neighbor and bring that poor creature inside. - Animals deserve care and protection. Providing a safe and warm place to sleep is not spoiling, it's simply living up to your duties as a caring owner. My dogs are family members, they live inside with us and are actively involved in every part of our lives. They get outside playtime and plenty of exercise, but they spend the majority of their time following me around the house and interacting with me. I think it's a sad and lonely life for a dog to be consigned to the outdoors.
Cold weather can lead to a number of hazards such as hypothermia and freezing of the extremities. I work at a vet clinic and I've helped recover (or try to recover) several animals who have had very low body temperatures. I've also helped amputate tips of ears and tails that have frozen. A fur coat is not necessarily protection against freezing winters and pets belong indoors and safe. - that sounds like animal abuse after the storm we just had!!
- I am a retired Animal Control Officer. Your neighbor is not an animal lover nor does he care how to treat an animal properly. Dogs are social animals and need the companionship of their human owner. If you are going to have a pet, it needs to be with you as a companion at least part of the day or at night. Winter time in cold climates is no time to leave a dog outside alone in the cold. Dogs tied up and left alone as just a yard dog can become anti social eventually. If you work all day or at school all day and your dog is not trustworthy in the house alone, then do leave him at his dog house with maybe a good outdoor light bulb fixed up in his house if it is big or just fixed to the outside by the door so a little heat gets to him, then bring him in when you are home so he has company. It is a lonely and cruel life to just leave a dog outside in bitter cold all the time without your companionship and attention. Don't listen to your neighbor anymore and follow your instincts. You are right. This also applies to very hot summers. No matter the weather, a dog needs human interaction and depending on the breed, their coats are not always sufficient to keep them comfortable in extreme weather conditions.
- Why would you take the advice of a neighbor who hasn't a clue? I feel very sorry for the dogs who are not being properly cared for by this know-all who has no idea how to look after a dog.
Bring the dog inside the house. My dogs live inside all year round. We live in a safe area and I have high fences. My dogs have the choice of being inside the house or outside. They choose to be inside with their family.
I don't consider my dogs to be spoiled, they are well cared for and well behaved and obedience trained.