I AM NOT LOOKING FOR A DOG TO ABUSE NOR AM I THE TYPE OF PERSON THAT WILL JUST THROW A DOG OUTSIDE & EXPECT IT TO BITE ANYONE PASSING BY.
I live on 3 acres, but my house is in the front on one acre. I have plenty of space for a dog to run around, play & be happy. I want a guard dog or mabye 2. I want to buy it as a puppy so that I can raise it & so that I dont buy a dog thats already an adult & might turn out vicious. As soon as it gets old enough to the right age, I'll send it to a Guard Dog Training School. Which should I get????????
Recommended Answer:
I have owned both. Go with the pincher. Our rottweilers just like to be scrated and fart alot. the doberman is more alert and barks to alert us , she dosent bite but the intruders dont know that.our front gate has a sign that reads "our dogs can make it from the door to the gate in 3 seconds CAN YOU?"
Read More...
I live on 3 acres, but my house is in the front on one acre. I have plenty of space for a dog to run around, play & be happy. I want a guard dog or mabye 2. I want to buy it as a puppy so that I can raise it & so that I dont buy a dog thats already an adult & might turn out vicious. As soon as it gets old enough to the right age, I'll send it to a Guard Dog Training School. Which should I get????????
A Long Tradition of Dog Training
Recommended Answer:
I have owned both. Go with the pincher. Our rottweilers just like to be scrated and fart alot. the doberman is more alert and barks to alert us , she dosent bite but the intruders dont know that.our front gate has a sign that reads "our dogs can make it from the door to the gate in 3 seconds CAN YOU?"
Dog Training Methods - How to Train Your Dog
- A dog's basic temperament is set by its genetics, so if a puppy is mentally sound it will not mature into an adult dog that randomly takes a chunk out of someone.
The average pet Dobermann {not purchased from a kennel that specifically breeds their dogs to work....few & far between} would make an excellent visual deterrent & watch dog to bark an alarm, but would not protect its human pack.
You would need an adult professionally trained protection dog .....be prepared to dig deep into your wallet or a puppy bred to work & then assuming the dog passes an evaluation by a professional dog trainer, be prepared to invest fairly heavily to pay for its training. - Have you considered getting a "Guardian" breed instead of a "guard" breed? Anatolians, Grt Pyrenees, are just 2 guardian breeds. They are naturals at alerting to intruders (4-legged or 2-legged) they patrol their home turf easily. They are not aggressive but can be quite intimidating just by their size and demeanor. They were mostly bred to live with and guard livestock. But I have found that they adapt to whatever their "herd" is - people, cats, other dogs.
Otherwise, get a well bred German bloodline GSD-- they have the instincts and intelligence left in them to do just about any job you want. - Any breed of dog can be trained to be a guard dog - even the smallest. You don't necessarily want a big, fierce, high-strung dog that could attack someone it shouldn't...just think of how much you could lose when the victim of such an attack sues your pants off! Get whichever breed of dog appeals to you and then take it to school - don't send it; go with it - 'cause you need to learn how properly to manage a dog with that special set of skills!
- I personally love Rottweilers.There very loyal dogs who wont wonder off very far.I have a 2 yr old male he looks scary but hes the most friendliest dog.That's all a person needs is a dog who looks scary that way they will stay out of your yard.Do some research on both breeds,if you can go and meet a rotti pup then a dobi pup.best of luck to you.
- Neither one of these 2 breeds will do it. Adult dogs that are properly bred and raised do not turn vicious. Look into getting an adult so you know up front what you are buying and be ready to spend several thousand dollars!! Hope I helped!
- NOT breed specific!
If you're truly this ignorant,you're incapable of proper management.
SANE & trained animals don't...can't..."turn out vicious". - Dobermanns don't need guard dog training. In fact, most breeders will tell you to avoid bringing this breed there as it will cause aggressive behaviours that you will not want to deal with.
If you go for a Dobermann, get it from a really good breeder!
Some people say that the "guard dog" instinct has been bred out of the Dobermann and I'm not sure how you can prove if that's fact or fiction. I know my guy is perfect as a personal protection dog (no training) and he's almost 1 year old this month.
Not too sure about Rotties - I've never personally dealt with the breed.
EDIT: Why are so many of you not reading the question properly? lol He said HE DOES NOT WANT THE DOG TO TURN VICIOUS. Not that he does want it to be. So the answers about breeds being bred properly will never turn vicious are irrelevant. - "Guard Dog Training School"??? What the hell is that? Billy Bob's Beat'em & Bill ya later Training Kennel?! - Dutchman
LMFAO, oh my spleen! Ahhh man that 1 hurt me! That's exactly what it is.
IF you could find a Doberman capable of the work, you'd spend more for it than an entry level luxury car. If you found a Rottie capable of the work, which would be easier, but difficult for anyone without ties to top importers/an importer him/herself...still expect to pay a good deal of cash. Always best to buy a trained adult and learn how to handle it. Lol Dutch you're too much! Btw I had a Rottie not too long ago from Slovakia, he was a great little working dog! Ugly as sin though, the Slovaks like smaller bully faced Rotties, they pull their weight though. - Aphrodite- Your idea of a Personal Protection dog must be very much different than mine.
It would be impossible to have a 1 year old dog without training be a PPD.
A dog that alerts or barks when a stranger is around is not a PPD.
And true PPD training will not make the dog aggressive, quite the opposite in fact.
Whether you can prove the working ability has been bred out of Dobies may be hard to substantiate, but from the many people I have heard from who do this for a living, the consensus is that they are not a preferred breed for that reason. Since this is Greekman's field of expertise, I would listen to his advice.